Oh no! That's worse then writing a sentence 100 times like they did when I was in school.
The question is...does your child know what they did wrong and why it was wrong and what will they do the next time a similar situation presents itself? I guess you can discuss that with them. Life's lessons.
Kid and I had talk. Here in China, students often get physical punishment from teachers. This teacher insist on intellectual punishment, turn punishment into more schoolwork. I guess problem stemmed from not writing correctly. So she made kid write for punishment.
In my mind punishment seems to be the wrong approach until after positive reinforcement is not working. I have a big problem with punishment as a motivator because it more often than not it is just the beginning of a negative/downward spiral. For example, I've read that Amazon punishes their warehouse packers if they don't pack X amount of packages per hour. It would make more sense to me to offer bonus' for packers that exceed X packages per hour. Incentives work wonders, but the caveat is they must be obtainable or all is lost.
Windlyn is so fun, Windlyn is so grand, So come on everyone, All across the land, Come and join us now, In this awesome site, We will show you how, Talking through the night. ~npixelz
writing more means more practice, that is for sure.
Physical punishment is not allowed here in our State and a Teacher can lose their job if they do. Punishments are sometimes "time outs", extra duties, writing "I will not -",(or whatever they are trying to impress), loss of privileges.
Galled, I think maybe that help more. China is very set in discipline though, I not sure how many would even try it just look at it as being too gentle. I try both. My kids are good kids but not perfect. So maybe I do something right. I hope.
In Chinese writing, you must write in certain order called stroke order and this kid doesn't like following it. Not sure why it seems to be so difficult but they really don't like using it but then characters are written incorrect and it shows.
I think teachers should not hit the students and not all schools allow it but it very prevalent here. I see nothing good about hitting children.
I was looking at your first post where you said" Finger ketou 磕头 (cant. Kowtow) is knocking your fingers on the table to show gratitude for your tea pourer, usually someone at the table. "
I always thought the finger tapping meant to keep pouring!
Kowtow is a tradition before emperor where one kneel down so far his head touch the ground. Kowtow consist of the characters for "knocking" and "head". It was sign of deep respect. So, finger Kowtow sign of respect for server. I want to attend Yincha on trip to Hong Kong.