by galled » Fri Mar 24, 2023 11:02 am
As I've said, relationships (especially the early ones--and lasting ones) are learning experiences, so I hope none of this makes you feel bad. It is my belief that true learning means correcting/not making the same mistakes--understanding the problem is only half of the equation.
The common thread I see is lost/lack of communication.
Definitely in #1.
I realize that movies are not real life, but that doesn't mean the basics are not based on truth and that there's nothing to learn (I believe all of life's mysteries are answered in the movies). The basic formula for all romantic movies (gender is irrelevant and you can replace either with names or even numbers):
Boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy finds girl, they live happily ever after.
A common plot device (in screenwriting these are "triggers" to throw the characters into a situation--the more dramatic, the more interesting the story) is misunderstanding. Of course the rest of the story is about resolving the problem so they can move on.
Did you try to follow up on why you never heard back from #1? Did you try and apologize after your friend told you she tried to contact you? Did you just lose interest? Do you think she might feel bad she never heard back from you? Could you be friends still if these things were cleared up?
The basic component of all worthy relationships is friendship. Be friends first and always. If you can't/don't have that, it won't last.
#2 and #3, why you "broke up" is unknown, but it doesn't sound like someone said, "I hate you," "I never want to talk to you again," "I want to break up with you" or anything like that. Most would remember something like that. You probably need to ask yourself some hard questions. Did you lose interest and ghosted them? Did you not want to be friends with either? Since you have contact channels with them still, is it them or you that ended things? Could you be friends with either?
I listed empathy as a component of good relationships. Try and see situations from the other person's perspective. No one wants to push a friendship that's unwanted by the other party. Silence/ghosting from the other is a sign that they are not interested in being at the very least friends. This happens due to fear/lack of self-confidence, outside interference, timing, etc. (the list goes on and on--see romance movies), but unless one of you asks the questions/tries to find out where things are, it ends even if both parties would like to continue. Yes, lack of response (ghosting from the other side) is an answer, but double-checking that you're at least communicating is at the very least, due diligence if you like them enough to be friends. How tragic are the stories about romances that stall out because the post office loses a proposal letter from a soldier overseas (time period films) or due to the sister/step-mother/rival sabotaging the communication between the protagonists?
It's OK to ask questions, doubly so for people who mean something to you. They can reject you (and it will happen), but it works the same as it works for you--if someone makes an effort to be your good friend, you'll make an effort to consider it and be a good one back (unless they're very broken--a whole other challenge that in many cases is not fixable). Unfortunately it works the opposite way too. If the other party doesn't make an effort to contact you, you can think they're not interested, so you think I don't want to contact them because they're not interested in being friends. This is how they can see it too. (Downward spiral.)
Another plot device in romance movies is the close friend. The friend does the communicating (and sometimes the interpretation of the state of the relationship for the audience to keep up) between the two protagonists. It's all very high school, and most eventually learn that communication is always best directly between the respective parties.
Hope this helps!