It's an everyday vegetable here too... but fresh bell peppers don't taste like paprika to me and I honestly never researched it before! (Some chef I am...which I obviously am not)
Nyuu, I think Gizzie has three accounts, (Gremmie and Hugs & Kisses), so hopefully she may have extra feather rain to trade or sell later... you can check with her or put it on a personal quest later.