by Mousy » Wed Mar 11, 2015 4:14 pm
I haven't seen the newest adaptation of the book, but I did read the book 7 or so years ago and I saw the older movie adaptation. That being said, I may be rusty on the book. Haha
Unpopular opinion time~
If I were faced with the same decision that Daisy had to make, I feel like I would choose Tom. She had a family with Tom and years of memories. Tom could also provide Daisy with a security that Gatsby never could. Yes, they both had money, but Gatsby was so loose with it and if I remember correctly, it wasn't attained in the most honorable way. I know that Tom had his mistress, but even still, that can be worked out (especially since she wasn't really a problem at the end....). I just feel like Gatsby was so intense and Daisy built up this life while he was gone. It wouldn't be fair for him to take her away from that. Tom is presented as a big jerk, but I think any male would be if there was someone else threatening his life and marriage. I'm not saying that any of Daisy's actions were okay, because she definitely led Gatsby on, but I would make the same decision in the end I think.